On January 1, 2027, Alberta's auto insurance system is undergoing one of its biggest changes in decades. The new Care-First auto insurance system will introduce expanded medical benefits, income replacement, and permanent impairment benefits for people injured in automobile accidents.
One of the biggest changes is that the ability to sue an at-fault driver for injuries will be significantly restricted. With fewer bodily injury lawsuits expected, many Alberta drivers are asking an important question:
The short answer is yes. For most Alberta drivers, maintaining $2 million in liability coverage is still a smart decision. If you’re satisfied with that answer, then you don’t need to keep reading. If you’re interested in the “why”, then stick around.
One of the primary goals of Care-First is to reduce the cost of auto insurance by changing how injury claims are handled. Historically, bodily injury claims have accounted for a significant portion of Alberta's total auto insurance claim costs.
Consider how claims changed between 2019 and 2024:
|
Auto Insurance Claims |
2019 |
2024 |
% Change |
|
Total claims paid |
$2.9 billion |
$5.1 billion |
+75.86% |
|
Bodily injury claims paid |
$1.4 billion |
$2.5 billion |
+78.57% |
|
Number of bodily injury claims |
17,882 |
14,096 |
-21.17% |
|
Average bodily injury claim cost |
$79,739 |
$178,609 |
+123.99% |
While the number of bodily injury claims decreased by 21.2%, the average cost of each claim increased by approximately 124% in just 6 years. In other words, insurers were handling fewer injury claims, but those claims were becoming significantly more expensive.
Alberta's litigation-based system contributed to these rising costs. Some estimates suggested that as much as 20% of auto insurance premiums were being spent on litigation-related expenses. Care-First is designed to change that.
Rather than relying as heavily on lawsuits to compensate injured drivers, the new system will provide expanded accident benefits directly through insurance, while restricting lawsuits in most circumstances.
The goal is to direct more money toward care and recovery while reducing the overall cost of auto insurance.
Although Care-First significantly changes how bodily injury claims are handled, it does not eliminate the need for third-party liability insurance. Liability insurance helps protect you financially when you are legally responsible for injuries or property damage caused to others.
If you are responsible for an accident that damages someone else's property, you could be held financially responsible. This could include damage to:
The cost of repairing or replacing damaged property continues to rise. Vehicles are becoming more expensive to repair, construction costs have increased, and even relatively ordinary accidents can result in substantial property damage.
Now imagine a more serious accident. You lose control of your vehicle and crash into a commercial building. The accident causes extensive structural damage, destroys valuable equipment, and forces the business to temporarily close. Depending on the circumstances, the total damages could exceed $1 million.
If the damages exceed your liability insurance limit, you could be personally responsible for the difference.
Imagine you're responsible for an accident that results in $1.5 million in covered liability damages.
|
$1 Million Coverage |
$2 Million Coverage |
|
|
Total damages |
$1,500,000 |
$1,500,000 |
|
Insurance pays |
$1,000,000 |
$1,500,000 |
|
Your potential responsibility |
$500,000 |
$0 |
This simplified example assumes the damages are covered by the policy and that the insured is legally responsible for the full amount.
That additional protection can make an enormous difference.
For many Alberta drivers, increasing their liability coverage from $1 million to $2 million is relatively inexpensive. Depending on your insurer, vehicle, driving history, and other rating factors, the additional coverage may cost approximately $10–$20 per month.
That's roughly $120–$240 per year for an additional $1 million in liability protection. While nobody wants to pay more for insurance than necessary, the potential financial consequences of being underinsured can be significant.
Care-First represents a major change to Alberta's auto insurance system. With fewer bodily injury lawsuits expected, the types of claims made against liability insurance may change considerably. However, fewer lawsuits do not mean no financial risks.
Property damage claims can still be extremely expensive, and certain bodily injury lawsuits will remain possible. For most Alberta drivers, maintaining $2 million in third-party liability coverage remains a sensible way to protect their finances.
Before reducing your coverage, speak with your insurance broker about the potential risks and how much you could actually save.
At Armour Insurance, we believe good insurance advice is about more than finding the lowest price. It's about helping you understand your coverage, your options, and the financial risks you're protecting yourself against.
or